Financial planning

Phone insurance, a warranty, cover from my card or my energy bill: why don’t they pay, and how do I stop them?

A cracked screen, theft “from an unattended bag”, an insurance on your bill you don’t remember asking for, renewals that never stop. What EIOPA flags about these products, what to ask, and how to cancel.

By AVRASTRO · · 12 min read

In short

The European authority EIOPA flags that such products often have low claims ratios, automatic renewals and exclusions that narrow cover. You can stop them in writing, before the renewal date.

  • Check card statements and bills for insurance you pay without knowing.
  • For each one, find out which company issues it and ask for the full terms.
  • Stop the ones you do not need in writing before renewal, and keep proof.
  • Before borrowing, ask whether the insurance is compulsory or whether you can bring your own.

From the series “The questions you are afraid to ask”, part “When something goes wrong”: questions real people ask, with honest answers.

At a glance

  • EIOPA flags that products sold alongside others (telecom, energy, gadgets) often have low claims ratios, high commissions, automatic renewals and exclusions that narrow cover.
  • Always ask for the name of the company that issues the cover and the full terms, not only the leaflet.
  • To stop a renewal, say so in writing before its date and keep proof.
  • An AI tool is not a registered insurance intermediary.

Small amounts, big frustration

You pay a few euros a month for your phone, a warranty, a cover that came with your card or your bill. And when you need it, you hear “not covered”. The amounts may be small, but the feeling of being taken for a ride is not. Here you will find what the European supervisors say about these products, what to ask before you keep them, and how to cancel them if they are no use to you.

What EIOPA flags

In its 2025 trends report, EIOPA (the European insurance authority) notes that products sold through energy and telecom companies have low claims ratios, high commissions, automatic renewals and exclusions that narrow cover, and it singles out gadget insurance. According to the Eurobarometer of the same year, in the EU 24% of people who bought insurance in the last two years did so only online, 9% used AI tools and 30% trust AI recommendations; some may think such tools are registered intermediaries when they are not. In the United Kingdom (not Cyprus), there were 520 gadget insurance complaints in 2024/25, and 31% were decided in the consumer’s favour.

Payment protection on loans

EIOPA’s thematic review (2022, across the EEA, not specific to Cyprus) of payment protection sold by banks found average claims ratios of about 26% of premiums for mortgages, 18% for consumer credit and 8% for credit cards, and commissions to banks of 40% to 80% of the premium. 83% of banks sold it tied to the loan, 43% of insurers needed the bank’s approval before a customer could cancel, and 20% to 30% of claims were refused. We found no figures specific to Cyprus.

Insurance, or just a warranty?

Not everything called “cover” is an insurance contract. An extended warranty may be insurance from an insurer or simply a promise by the shop or manufacturer. The difference matters for where you complain: the Financial Ombudsman examines complaints against insurers supervised by the Superintendent of Insurance. We could not confirm this product by product, so ask in writing who issues it and who supervises it.

If you disagree: the complaint route

  1. Ask for the reason in writing. With the exact policy clause and the evidence (reports, assessments) the decision relied on.
  2. A written complaint to the insurer. Within 6 months of learning of the problem. The insurer must reply within the time set in its complaints procedure; the Superintendent of Insurance’s guide says up to 45 days.
  3. The Financial Ombudsman. If there is no reply or it is vague. A €20 fee, in writing, in Greek or English, within 12 months of the written complaint. Claims against insurers up to €20,000 are examined by the Deputy Ombudsman; a decision up to €20,000 binds both sides.
  4. The courts. Always open, usually slower and more costly, with a lawyer. If you go to court, the Ombudsman’s examination stops.

The practical steps, with letter templates you can copy: How to build your case.

What went wrong for others — and how to avoid it

  • Loan insurance was sold tied to the loan, and the refund was missed on early repayment (EU, not specific to Cyprus). Before signing, ask whether the insurance is required, whether you can bring your own, what the commission is and what happens on early repayment. If you repay early, ask in writing for the refund of the unused premium.
  • The exclusions of loan insurance were not explained (EU). Ask for the policy terms, not only the bank’s leaflet, and read the job-loss and disability sections before you sign.
  • A “small” cover renewed automatically for years without being used (EU). Once a year, check card statements and bills for insurance you do not need, and stop it in writing before renewal.

Your questions, one by one

I bought phone insurance in the shop and my cracked screen claim was refused. Why are these policies so hard to claim on?

Read the reason for the refusal and the terms: such policies often have exclusions, an excess and conditions, such as reporting quickly or using an approved repairer. EIOPA has flagged gadget insurance and products sold alongside others as areas with low claims ratios and exclusions that narrow cover. Ask in writing for the clause the refusal relied on. If you disagree, complain; in the United Kingdom (not Cyprus), 31% of gadget insurance complaints in 2024/25 were decided in the consumer’s favour.

My phone insurance excludes theft ‘from an unattended bag’. What counts as unattended?

It depends on the policy’s definition: “unattended” often means out of your sight or reach, or not under your control. Ask in writing for the exact definition and explain the circumstances, with the police report. If the definition is unclear for your situation, say so in your complaint.

The electricity or telecom company added an insurance product to my bill that I don’t remember agreeing to. Can I cancel and get refunds?

Ask the company in writing for proof of your agreement (a signed form, a recording or online acceptance) and the policy documents. If you did not agree, say so and ask for cancellation and a refund of what you paid. EIOPA has flagged insurance sold through energy and telecom companies, with automatic renewals and high commissions, as a consumer risk. If they refuse, make a written complaint.

Is the extended warranty offered at the electronics shop real insurance, and who do I complain to?

It depends: some extended warranties are insurance contracts from an insurer, others a promise by the shop or the manufacturer. Ask in writing who issues it and whether it is supervised as insurance. If it is insurance from an insurer supervised by the Superintendent of Insurance, the Financial Ombudsman can examine a complaint; otherwise other consumer routes may apply. We could not confirm this for every product, so check case by case.

Add-on insurance renews every year automatically and I keep paying for something I never use. How do I stop it?

Tell the company in writing that you do not want a renewal, before its date, and keep proof. Stop the standing order or card payment after you have told them, to avoid disputes. If it has already renewed, ask in writing for cancellation and a refund for the period you will not use. EIOPA has flagged automatic renewals as a consumer risk.

My bank started charging a fee on the standing order that pays my insurance premium, without telling me. Is that allowed?

Ask your bank in writing which charge it applies, when it told you and under which terms. In Greece (not Cyprus), such charges on premium standing orders were refunded after the Consumer Ombudsman intervened. Bank charges are a matter between you and your bank; if the bank does not answer, the Financial Ombudsman also examines complaints against banks.

My legal protection insurance refused to fund my case, saying it was ‘not worth pursuing’. Who decides that?

Some legal protection policies fund a case only if it has reasonable prospects of success, and the insurer judges that, often with a lawyer’s opinion. Ask in writing for the reasons and the opinion it relied on, and whether there is a procedure for disagreement, such as an independent lawyer’s view. If you disagree, follow the complaint route.

My pet insurance refused the vet bill as a ‘pre-existing condition’ because the vet noted something a year ago. Is that fair?

Pet policies usually exclude conditions that showed signs before cover began, and a vet’s note can count as such a sign. Ask in writing which note was used and how the policy defines a pre-existing condition. If the earlier note concerned something else, get a written statement from your vet and complain. In the United Kingdom (not Cyprus), 42% of pet insurance complaints in 2024/25 were decided in the consumer’s favour.

My business-interruption cover refused to pay when I was forced to close by a government order. Why?

Business interruption cover often requires physical damage to the premises, unless the policy has specific extensions, for example for disease or denial of access. Ask in writing which clause was applied and read the extensions. If the wording is unclear for your situation, raise it in a complaint, and for a business dispute speak to a lawyer.

I bought insurance through an app in two minutes. If something goes wrong, who do I complain to?

First to the company that issued the policy, which should be named in the documents: find the insurer’s name and its complaints contact. If the insurer is supervised by the Superintendent of Insurance, you can then go to the Financial Ombudsman. Keep screenshots of what you saw and accepted, and the confirmation e-mail.

An AI chatbot recommended an insurance policy to me. Is that the same as advice from a licensed intermediary?

No. An AI tool is not a registered insurance intermediary, and EIOPA notes that some people may think it is. In the EU, 9% used AI tools when buying insurance, and 30% say they trust AI recommendations. Use it to understand terms if you like, but check who sells the policy, and for your needs speak to a registered intermediary.

The insurance I got with my credit card has so many exclusions that it seems to cover nothing. Is it worth anything?

It may be worth something, but only for what it actually covers. Ask for the full terms, not only the leaflet, and check conditions such as paying with the card, the limits and the exclusions. Do not rely on it as your only cover without checking.

I was sold payment protection on a consumer loan for a TV. Is it worth keeping, and can I cancel it?

Check whether it was required for the loan and what it covers: often job loss, illness or death, with waiting periods and exclusions. EIOPA found across the EU that such insurance was often sold tied to loans, with low claims ratios (about 18% of premiums for consumer credit) and high commissions to banks. Ask in writing whether you can cancel, which refund applies and what happens if you repay early.

My home-emergency cover took four days to send a plumber. Isn’t ’emergency’ supposed to mean fast?

Check what the policy promises: some set response times, others only “as soon as possible”, and limits may apply. Ask in writing why it took four days and what the policy says. If you paid for an emergency repair yourself, ask whether it can be refunded. In the United Kingdom (not Cyprus), 39% of home emergency complaints in 2024/25 were decided in the consumer’s favour.

Roadside assistance refused to tow my car because the breakdown was ‘at home’, not on the road. Is that a real exclusion?

Some roadside policies cover breakdowns only away from home, and “at home” cover is an extra. Check the definition in your policy and the level you bought. If the wording was unclear, mention it in your complaint, and ask about upgrading if you need it.

Questions worth asking in writing

  • Which company issues this cover, and who supervises it?
  • Can I have the full terms, with the exclusions and the excess?
  • Does it renew automatically, and how do I stop it?
  • Is it required for the loan, or can I bring my own cover?

What you can do from today

  • Check card statements and bills for insurance you pay without knowing it.
  • For each one, find out who issues it and ask for the full terms.
  • Stop the ones you do not need in writing before renewal, and keep proof.
  • Before borrowing, ask whether the insurance is required and what happens on early repayment.
  • If you are refused, ask for the clause in writing and make a written complaint within 6 months.

General information, not advice (legal or insurance). Every policy has its own terms; for your own case, the law and what your policy says apply. For general insurance (car, home, travel, liability) speak to a general-business intermediary or your insurer, and for a legal dispute to a lawyer. AVRASTRO is not an insurer.

Read also: Loan insurance: whom does it protect? · Loan insurance: what is worth knowing · Covers in plain words · Glossary of insurance terms · Cancellation, non-renewal and age · How to build your case, with letter templates · All the questions you are afraid to ask

Send it to someone

WhatsApp (opens the app) E-mail (opens the app)

Send it to your son or daughter A ready message asking them to help you read it together.

By WhatsApp (opens the app) By e-mail (opens the app)

Only the page link is sent, never your figures or results.

This article is for information. Figures apply at the publication date and may change; talk to an advisor about your own situation.

Cyprus

How do I change the beneficiary, lower the premium or cancel my policy properly?

A practical guide to what you do with a policy you already have: the law’s 30-calendar-day right to withdraw and its exceptions, changing the beneficiary, lowering the premium, two policies, a certificate for the tax office, moving abroad, and what to do if they kept charging you.

Discover more from AVRASTRO

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading